Skip to main content

DoodleMaths Review 2.0


DoodleMaths is a website and application developed by Ez Education as part of a family of apps, that includes DoodleTables, DoodleEnglish, and DoodleSpell which specialise in teaching children between the ages of 4 and 14 about their times tables, English, and spelling respectively. A further app called DoodleConnect is a parent app that allows them to monitor their child’s progress within the other apps.
DoodleMaths, as the name suggests, focuses on mathematics in general. The app uses an algorithm called Proxima that takes in the student’s results and the national curriculum for the child’s age in order to provide questions that give a suitable challenge (EZ Education, 2019). These kind of algorithms have been found to be greatly beneficial to students who are performing at an average or below average level, although the research has found that students performing at a higher than average level do not experience the same benefits (Geçer, & Dağ, 2012; Richards-Babbs et al., 2018; Roschelle, Feng, Murphy, & Mason, 2016). In my experience the app has been used to deliver homework and utilises the Proxima algorithm to progress students through the national curriculum at the child’s own pace. However, if a parent feels the app is moving their child onto work that is too challenging, then they can request the class teacher to force the app to recalibrate the child’s abilities.
My experience with the app has entirely come from my younger brother’s homework during Year 1 in primary school. In my experience, the questions and topics set for him to learn through the DoodleMaths’ “New This Week” mode have been steadily increasing in difficulty, but in such a way that he is building on what has come before, such as one week’s topic discussing how to add 9, and then the following week’s topic focusing on how to subtract 9. Each week he brings home a new certificate and has managed to maintain a streak of 150 consecutive days. However, the app does give students and parents some breathing room in this regard as if you miss a day then you can catch up by completing two days’ worth of worth the following day.
However, while the research suggests that the use of the Proxima algorithm to progress students at their own pace is a good thing for students performing below average, there is also an air of caution must come alongside it. David Winter (2019), a concerned parent, noted in his review on the Google Play Store that his son had become disillusioned with the app as he compared the number of stars earned to his friends and classmates through the social media aspects of the app. These aspects include the ability to send messages to other classmates or to the teacher (although I’ve not seen this in practice as my brother’s account has bugged out, making it so that he can’t send messages, despite the teachers looking into it), as well as a space to design a robot where you buy accessories using the “DoodleStars” that you’ve collected by completing questions. Teachers can also utilise the app in school time, allowing students to compare the questions they are being given as well as the difficulty of the questions, which isn’t particularly hard to do seeing as the number of questions you have to complete is reliant on how well you have done up until this point. Dunn and Darlington’s 2016 study found that students were able to identify when easier work was being given to them over their peers, which could be extended to how the Proxima algorithm assigns work, with the teacher simply being swapped out with a computer programme. This could result in decreased student moral in comparison to more traditional homework methods where the results are not typically seem by the rest of the class as well as everyone completing the same work. As such, through a combination of low star results, comparing themselves to their friends, and the app providing easy questions, students could also fall into self-fulfilling prophecies where because they are always given simpler work than their classmates, they begin to see themselves as rubbish at mathematics and disengage from the homework (Jussim, Robustelli, & Cain, 2009).

The main mode of the application is the daily question mode that begins with 5 questions a day, although as students progress, this can increase to 6 or 7 questions a day. These questions increase in difficulty based on how well students perform. After completing several of these daily tests, the “New This Week” section of the app becomes available which attempts to teach students a new concept. These small lessons are extremely small in scope (such as a single lesson on how to effectively add 9), and so can help students progress without throwing multiple new concepts at them. However, an issue that I’ve encountered with these is that they appear to favour lots of words over pictures, which while fine for older children with better reading ages, but younger children who aren’t as confident in terms of reading may struggle to make sense of these explanations without adult help. This idea is further complicated as they use more complex mathematical terms such as “quotient” within the explanations and questions, the meaning of which isn’t always common knowledge, leading to parents being unable to explain a question to their child whilst helping with their homework.

Overall, DoodleMaths is a helpful app that is able to enhance a student’s mathematical ability by encouraging them through the use of games, stars, and certificates. However, the application is held back by its potential to discourage students for which mathematics does not come naturally as well as the advanced mathematical terms that it chooses to use with 5 year olds who have no reason to learn it.

References

Department for Education. (2013). Mathematics programmes of study: key stages 1 and 2. Department for Education.
Dunn, K., & Darlington, E. (2016). GCSE Geography teachers' experiences of differentiation in the classroom. International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 25(4), 344-357.
EZ Education. (2019, August). Technology that 'thinks' and sets children's work. Retrieved February 05, 2020, from DoodleMaths: www.doodlemaths.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/fact-sheet-proxima.pdf
Geçer, A., & Dağ, F. (2012). A Blended Learning Experience. Educational Sciences: Theory & Practice, 12(1), 438-442.
Jussim, L., Robustelli, S. L., & Cain, T. R. (2009). Teacher Expectations and Self-Fulfilling Prophecies. In K. R. Wentzel, & A. Wigfield (Eds.), Handbook of Motivation at School (pp. 349-380). New York: Routledge.
Richards-Babb, M., Curtis, R., Ratcliff, B., Roy, A., & Mikalik, T. (2018). General Chemistry Student Attitudes and Success with Use of Online Homework: Traditional-Responsive versus Adaptive-Responsive. Journal of Chemical Education, 95(5), 691-699.
Roschelle, J., Feng, M., Murphy, R. F., & Mason, C. A. (2016). Online Mathematics Homework Increases Student Achievement. AERA Open, 2(4), 1-12.
Seifert, T. L., & O'Keefe, B. A. (2001). The relationship of work avoidance and learning goals to perceived competence, externality and meaning. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 71(1), 81-92.
Winter, D. (2019, December 14). Review of DoodleMaths. Google Play Store. Retrieved February 05, 2020, from https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ezeducation.doodlemaths.ks2&hl=en_GB&reviewId=gp%3AAOqpTOGKYIdkXvzIl-O3TiBpbDkYaky3Z0Fa1nHBlPKvxppLav-NpKJcUeE6ETKGgPM9rrih_8ev5th7tPvnIeM

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

3 Potential Futures for Education and Technology

In this blog post I will be exploring some potential futures of education in regards to the ever increasing influence of technology. As technology develops, the field of education often adopts new devices into its arsenal of teaching tools, ranging from mobile phone apps and websites for homework to the introduction of interactive whiteboards to enhance the presentation quality offered by teachers. In this regard, I will look at the potential futures afforded to education by augmented reality technology, adaptive response algorithms, and distance learning opportunities and the positive and negative aspects of their introduction. Historically, research has looked to recreational technology like video games in order to identify the core features that help to maintain children’s motivation whilst playing in order to improve educational games (Hedberg, & Alexander, 1994). This has led to education following and adopting recreational technologies for their own use in order to ma...

The potential affordances and constraints of using AR in Education

In this blog post, I will be offering a brief discussion on the affordances and potential constraints of utilising Augmented Reality (AR) technology within an educational context. Affordances have been defined by Norman (1988, p. 9, as cited in Churchill, Fox, & King, 2012, p. 251) as “the   perceived   and   actual   properties   of   the   thing,   primarily   those   fundamental   properties that determine just how the thing could possibly be used”. My understanding of this definition in relation to technology is that affordances of a piece of technology refers to the potential uses of the technology within an educational setting. One potential use of AR technology is through “location-based AR”. This version of AR can revolve around an interactive problem-solving video game such as having students work in teams to try to solve a suspicious death using team work and their knowledge of scientific concepts to understand...

Contemporary education in relation to a technologically infused education future

In this post, I will be discussing the idea of contemporary learning, including what it means to me and how I believe it could be realized in the field of education today as digital technologies become more and more prevalent within schools. Despite the phrase seemingly being common knowledge amongst the articles that I have read, I would like to begin identifying a definition of contemporary learning as it is a phrase that conjures a different image in my head to the general consensus. Contemporary learning refers to modern learning, such that an article from the 1970s that refers to contemporary learning will be referring to the learning trends that were around in the 1970s. More recent contemporary learning theories and approaches are typically focused on “multiple intelligence theory, cooperative learning, problem-based learning, [and] constructivism” as well as others (Şad, Kiş, & Demir, 2017, p. 210), with these approaches incorporating students’ individual experiences to...